Autos and Defence: What Goes Inside

This is the second of five pieces. The first was an overview, and it argued one idea I want to test in every sector. Finish it here, sell it to many, built by many. Make more of the end of the chain in Canada, the part that goes inside. Sell it to a lot of customers instead of one. And let a lot of makers do the work, not just a few big ones. This piece takes that idea into autos and defence, where it's furthest along and where it's being tested hardest right now, in Brampton.

Where we are

If you worked the line at Brampton Assembly, you haven't built a car there since December 2023, when the last Chargers and Challengers came off the line. The plant was supposed to retool for the next Jeep Compass. Then in October last year Stellantis moved the Compass to Illinois, and about 2,200 of you have been on layoff ever since. On November 9 Stellantis agreed to sell the building and its equipment to Roshel, a Brampton company that makes armoured vehicles. Your union called it a betrayal. So did the Prime Minister.

And if you work in Windsor, or Ingersoll, or at one of the parts shops in between, you've got your own date to watch. The American president has said tariffs on Canadian cars, parts and steel go to 50% on January 1. In August Washington offered 15% as part of a bigger deal, a lot of the industry said that still doesn't work, and Ottawa walked away. Informal talks go on. Either way it's hard to plan a life around.

So I'll start where I started last time. The fear is reasonable. About 125,000 people work directly in this industry, and a lot more in the towns around them. When the thing you've built your working life on gets sold out from under you, wanting it back is a natural reaction. I'd want it back too.

But I don't think the old auto business is coming back to Brampton, not in the old shape, and I think the people who'll do best are the ones who get to look at what could come next before someone else decides it for them.

What actually happened in Brampton

The facts, as best I can find them.

Stellantis signed the sale on November 9. The price wasn't disclosed and closing is expected by the end of the year. A source told the Globe and Mail that Stellantis will lease back about a quarter of the site for possible vehicle assembly, though no new Stellantis program for Brampton has been announced. Roshel says it isn't taking on Stellantis's obligations to the workers or joining the union talks.

Ottawa has money in this, a 2022 funding agreement worth up to $529 million for Brampton and Windsor, with about $222 million paid out, according to CBC. On November 12 Industry Minister Mélanie Joly served a notice of default, which gives Stellantis 30 days, until roughly December 12, to correct the conditions or face a lawsuit to get the money back. Stellantis has offered to return $24 million. Ottawa says that's nowhere near enough.

Now Roshel. Most Canadians hadn't heard of it until this fall, but the Ukrainian army certainly has. Roshel makes the Senator, an armoured vehicle built here in Brampton, and by Ukrainian count more than 2,500 of them had gone to Ukraine by this spring, including 383 that Canada paid for in February. It's a real company with real output, about 500 employees turning out something like 120 to 140 vehicles a month. In April it formed a joint venture with Algoma Steel to make ballistic steel in Canada. That last one matters more than it sounds, and I'll come back to it.

Roshel is also one of two Canadian finalists for the army's Light Utility Vehicle program, up to $4.9 billion for somewhere between 1,600 and 2,100 vehicles. Ottawa cut the two American bidders out of that competition in July. No winner has been named. If Roshel wins, the plan is to build them in Brampton.

The honest problems

I want to be fair to the union here, because their worries aren't reflexive.

Brampton is about three million square feet, roughly seven times everything Roshel runs today. Roshel is private, its financing isn't public, and the deal leans heavily on a military contract it hasn't won yet plus a letter of intent from a European automaker nobody has named. One estimate I saw had 700 to 1,000 of the 2,200 laid-off workers coming back, which would be a lot better than none, and still less than half. Roshel isn't unionized, and defence vehicle work generally doesn't pay what Big Three assembly paid. Unifor's Lana Payne made a point that stuck with me, that upfitting trucks is not the same thing as building vehicles. She's right about that.

So Carney's line from Dublin is about where I land. He called the Roshel deal a partial solution for the workers and said the rest is still owed by Stellantis. A step, in other words, not the answer.

Where I'd push a little further than the headlines is on what the answer might look like.

The bigger opportunity is defence

I covered this in the overview, so briefly.

Europe let us into SAFE, its 150 billion euro program for joint defence buying, and for Canada the usual limit on non-European parts is gone. We're the first non-European country in, and the United States is excluded by design. Two contracts so far, both in Montreal, Marconi making radios for Poland and Galvion making helmets for Latvia. Under the September partnership with Ukraine, Canadian companies are pairing up with Ukrainian ones, like Dominion Dynamics in Ottawa and Tencore building an unmanned ground vehicle here from 2027. At home, the Defence Industrial Strategy aims to send 70% of defence purchases to Canadian firms, and a new drone marketplace has qualified roughly 400 suppliers, with first contracts of up to $50 million against a goal of capacity for millions of drones within two years.

And the pitch I keep coming back to. Apart from the United States, Canada is the only big advanced manufacturing base in the alliance that sits an ocean away from Russia's front line. A Ukrainian partner said it plainly, that Canada has the factories, the suppliers and the reliable power, and it's out of missile range. So the ask to Europe isn't buy from us because we're friends. It's put your second production line here, because here it survives.

One caution, which I also raised last time. The fighter jet decision is still open, and the argument over F-35s versus Swedish Gripens gets heated. I'd only say don't throw away what we've already paid for in anger.

The gap

Here's where the core idea bites, and it's the one thing I'd most like a reader to take from this piece.

Almost every announcement above is about assembly. Roshel assembles vehicles. The drone makers mostly assemble drones. And when you look at what's inside, a lot of it comes from somewhere else.

The drone industry is the clearest case. Industry people describe most Canadian drone companies as integrators, meaning they bring in the motors, batteries and sensors and put them together here. One Canadian robotics CEO listed the gaps as microelectronics, battery cells and the permanent magnets that go into electric motors. China dominates the processing of the rare earths those magnets need. Even Project Arrow, the all-Canadian concept car at 97% Canadian content, still needed parts from Asia.

So we can design it and we can put it together. We can't yet make much of what goes inside it. That's the gap, and it's the same gap whether the vehicle is a crossover or a Senator or a quadcopter, the whole fleet if you will.

Which is why the Algoma steel deal matters. Armour plate is a part that goes inside, made from Canadian steel, in a Canadian mill, for a Canadian vehicle. That's a small finished-it-here story that's already true. So what if there were a dozen more like it? Motors. Battery cells. Optics. Flight controllers. Cathode and anode materials, where we have the minerals and the clean hydro power that European buyers increasingly care about. Every one of those could be its own business, or a few dozen businesses.

Small is beautiful

That last thought is the one I'd like to stay with for a minute, because it runs underneath this whole series.

In 1973 an economist named E. F. Schumacher wrote a book called Small Is Beautiful. I've been thinking about that title for most of my business life, kind of a quiet conviction that small business is where a lot of the answers are. And I think the moment we're in makes the case better than any book could.

Look at what's happened to warfare. Ukraine has nothing like Russia's defence budget, and it has held off a much bigger army in large part with cheap drones, built by a lot of small workshops, redesigned every few weeks as the other side adapts. A drone that costs a few hundred dollars can take out equipment worth millions. Small and fast has been beating big and slow, and the big militaries of the world are scrambling to learn from it.

The same goes for business. A small maker can change what it makes in weeks. A big auto plant takes years and billions to retool, and when Brampton's didn't work out, 2,200 people were left waiting. With the tools around now, AI among them, small shops can adapt faster than ever. The big players are a little like the Titanic. Very impressive, very hard to turn.

And Canada in particular is built for this. We're a huge country with not many people in it, spread out across thousands of kilometres. That's a weakness if everything depends on one giant plant in one city. It's a strength if the work is spread across a lot of smaller businesses in a lot of towns.

There's a resilience argument too, from home. We have solar panels on our roof. When a big grid goes down, thousands of homes go dark at once. Picture a neighbourhood where every house has solar and a battery. If one house goes down, the neighbours are still running. An industrial base works the same way. If one small business stumbles, the others carry on. When one giant plant stumbles, a whole community goes with it.

I made the beer argument in the overview, so just the short version. Molson and Labatt used to own most of the market. Now there are well over a thousand breweries in this country, the beer is a lot better, and if one craft brewery closes there are often three or four more in the same town to fill the gap.

Carney put it well in a speech to the European Parliament in September. "This is a ferocious storm. A single tree will come down in it. A forest will not." He was talking about Canada and Europe standing together, but I think it works just as well for an economy. One plant, one owner, one customer is a single tree, and it's how Brampton got here.

Brampton as a campus

So here's what that could look like in Brampton. It's an idea I floated in the overview update. I'll be clear up front that it's mine, nobody has announced anything like it, and Roshel owns the building, so it only happens with Roshel's agreement.

Picture the Brampton site as a shared campus, kind of an industrial park under one roof. Roshel as the anchor, building armoured and civilian vehicles. Stellantis in its quarter, if it actually puts something there. And around them, a lot of smaller makers. A component shop making motors for drones. A battery line. A specialty steel and armour finishing shop. Maybe, finally, the builder Project Arrow has been looking for. Roshel's own CEO has said he wants to bring other makers in, which is encouraging, though he hasn't said who.

Divided up, three million square feet is room for a lot of businesses that could never build a plant like that on their own. The power is connected, the rail and highway are right there, and the most valuable thing on the site is probably the people who know how to run a production line.

What would make it happen is patient money. The Canada Strong Fund, the $25 billion fund announced in the spring, names advanced manufacturing as a target, but it's still being set up and hasn't made an investment yet. So for now this is what it could be for. And the timing is interesting. Ottawa has a 30-day window with Stellantis, and the gap between $24 million and hundreds of millions is a fair bit of room to bargain in. Some of that could go into the campus instead of a courtroom. I'm not a lawyer and I don't know how that would work in practice, but it seems like a better use of the money than either side walking away.

Many makers on one site, selling to many customers. That's a forest.

New tools open new doors

Part of what makes a campus like that possible is that the tools have changed. Drones are one example, and they've changed the whole defence industry in about three years. 3D printing is another.

A traditional car plant stamps metal, pressing sheet steel into custom dies that cost a fortune and take months to make, so you need hundreds of thousands of the same part to pay for them. That's a big reason car making belongs to a handful of very large companies. Metal 3D printing builds a part up layer by layer from metal powder, straight from a computer file. No dies. Change the file and you change the part. Project Arrow's newest concept, Borealis, uses printed chassis and powertrain parts, and there's a company in Oakville, Burloak Technologies, that's been printing metal parts for aerospace and defence for years.

Printing is slower and costs more per part when you're making a million of the same thing, so it won't beat Detroit at Detroit's game. What it changes is who can get in the game at all. A small shop can make a few hundred parts without spending millions on tooling first. It's one tool among many, and in ten years it may be something else we haven't heard of yet. The point is that the cost of getting started keeps coming down, and that favours small.

A small aside. I've had a new hip for about a month now, and while I was reading up on all this I learned that some hip implant parts are 3D printed these days. I have no idea whether mine was. I didn't think to ask at the time, I was a little preoccupied. Anyhow.

The objections

A union member will say this is a fancy way of accepting lower wages. It's a fair worry, and I don't have a clean answer. What I'd say is that the components and the advanced manufacturing are where the skilled, better-paid work tends to sit, and that's the work I'm arguing for. Recall rights and pensions for the Brampton workers should be part of any public money that goes into that site, written in as a condition.

An economist will say defence demand rides on a war, and wars end. Also fair. If Ukraine got a ceasefire tomorrow, some of this would slow. But a lot of what's being built is useful in peacetime too. The BC Wildfire Service already uses drones with thermal cameras to map fires through smoke and at night, and this summer crews used a drone to light a controlled burn, a Canadian first. Drones help with floods and search and rescue. Historically a lot of the technology that serves people best came out of a war effort and was adapted to better times. So the point is to build capacity we can sell to many, flexible enough to move between uses, and not to bet on one conflict, which would be just another single customer.

Someone else will say sign whatever Washington wants and get the auto tariffs off. I hope a deal gets done, and if it does, good, the United States should stay a big customer. But an auto industry built entirely around one market across one border is what got Brampton here. A deal can lower the tariff. It can't make the one-customer risk go away.

And a sceptic will say Ottawa announces more than it delivers. The test for this file is fairly simple, and it's coming soon.

What I'd ask for

Picking up from the ten-point plan in the overview, the autos and defence pieces of it.

1. Spend the defence money in Canada first. ON TRACK. The 70% target is the right target. Patience, the contracts take time.

2. Use SAFE to bid into Europe. ON TRACK. Two contracts in, both Montreal firms. Now get more of the country bidding.

3. Turn the Ukraine partnership into contracts with dollar figures. ON TRACK, with patience needed. The company deals are landing, but the full agreement is still to come.

6. Pair every assembly announcement with a components plan. OPPORTUNITY, and Brampton is where it should start. Whoever wins the Light Utility Vehicle contract, make a share of what goes inside it Canadian too, on the Algoma model.

9. Put patient Canadian money behind Canadian technology that has no builder yet. OPPORTUNITY. The campus is one place to try it, and Project Arrow is the obvious first tenant.

10. Make support conditional, and enforce it. TESTED, outcome open. The December 12 deadline will tell us a lot.

And one new one, specific to this piece.

11. Grow the forest. GAP. When public money goes into manufacturing, set aside a real share for small and mid-sized makers, and help them get new tools, 3D printers, drone lines, whatever comes next. Let the military buy from them directly, the way the drone marketplace has started to. It's the fastest way I can see to get a lot of makers into the work.

What to watch

Before Christmas, Stellantis's answer to the notice of default, around December 12, and whether the Roshel sale closes. January 1, the American tariff deadline. Sometime soon, the Light Utility Vehicle award, and with it, what Brampton actually builds. Next year, TerMIT production with Tencore and Dominion. And in 2028, whether Project Arrow's commercially viable prototype shows up, and whether anyone has signed up to build it by then.

If a year from now Brampton is one plant with one owner doing contract assembly, the idea has been tested and not passed. If it's busy with a lot of makers, and some of what goes inside our drones and our armoured vehicles is made here, then it's working. We'll see.

What's next

The next piece is forestry, and Port Alberni, and the question I've been chewing on since the overview, whether a pulp mill could have a second life feeding Europe's propellant shortage.

Sources

Brampton and Stellantis

Roshel

Defence

Project Arrow and 3D printing

Small is beautiful